In a major reprieve for radiologists, the Bombay high court on Tuesday said that mere discrepancies and inadvertent mistakes in maintaining records, as envisaged under the Pre-Conception and Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) (PCPNDT) Act, 1994, cannot itself be the basis on which action is initiated against the doctor.
“Certain lacunae or simply omissions in the consent form should not be the basis to prosecute the person,” said the division bench of Justice AV Nirgude and Justice VL Achliya, while quashing the prosecution of Dr. Sai Shiradkar from Nanded.
The decision will bring reprieve for radiologists in general, as in most cases registered under the PCPNDT Act in Maharashtra, doctors have been booked for procedural lapses and discrepancies in their records.
In February 2015, members of the Regional Vigilance Squad at Aurangabad had inspected Shiradkar’sultrasonography centre and found discrepancies in the records, that seeks to punish sex-selective abortions, leading to female foeticide.
Action was initiated against her after the vigilance squad noticed discrepancies.
The doctor approached the high court last year seeking to quash the proceedings initiated against her, contending that none of the inadvertent mistakes could be regarded as intentional violation of the provisions of the Act.
The court upheld her contentions, saying that it was not a case wherein no record was maintained.
“The allegations made are so absurd that no prudent person can conclude that there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the petitioner (Dr. Shiradkar),” said the bench.
“In the case, the appropriate authority has failed to discharge its statutory obligation, which restricts to noting of certain lacunae, omissions and certain mistakes in maintenance of records. Mistakes without any criminal intent, that are merely procedural in nature, needs to be properly understood before taking drastic action,” said the high court.
Title – A title can be anything from a question, a heading of the article, or even the main topic about which you are publishing the post.
Description – It is explaining and adding the details about the topic you are posting. If you are asking a Question, then adding details is not necessary.
Photo, Video – You can attach a photo related to your post or can even publish a YOUTUBE video.
Sharing – Your name gets automatically attached behind the title of the article when you share is on Facebook or other platforms.
Eg: If a user John Watson have posted an article with the Title “How to handle Migraine without medicines?” and then if anyone share it on Facebook, the title will be like this :
“How to handle Migraine without medicines?”- John Watson
Themes of publishing or asking – You can publish from various themes that we mentioned and if any topic is missing among them, you can still post anything related to the Health. Healthcare is the only broad theme.
This data changes rapidly, so what’s shown may be out of date. Table totals may not always represent an accurate sum. Information about reported cases is also available on the World Health Organisation site.
It doesn’t include all cases
Confirmed cases aren’t all cases. They only include people who tested positive. Testing rules and availability vary by country.